Where Lilacs Still Bloom

February 20, 2012
Kirkpatrick's (The Daughter's Walk) latest work, a fictional account of real-life gardener Hulda Klager, was inspired by the German immigrant who came to be known as the Lilac Lady from Woodland, Wash. Beginning with her pursuit of a better baking apple, the book chronologically follows Klager's horticultural enterprises, most notably her creation of more than 250 distinct varieties of lilacs. Kirkpatrick's research ferreted out a woman who worked diligently, and in relative obscurity, simply for the love of her craft. Sadly, Klager's accomplishments were entwined with deeply personal tragedies, told with as much historical accuracy as possible. Her family's misfortunes and heartbreaks serve to reinforce Klager's belief in the value of ornamentals, but some readers may not sympathize with a woman who seems to care more for plants than for her family or their finances. In addition to Hulda's family members, additional characters join the story at random intervals, making the character listing at the front of the book most helpful in reminding readers who is who. Told primarily in Hulda's voice, the book meticulously explains her means and methods; however, the horticultural detail might tire those readers who are not flower fanatics..

April 15, 2012

Hulda Klager is a simple, 20th-century immigrant housewife. She begins trying to create an apple that will peel easily, but the hobby becomes an interest in hybridization. Her drive and dedication earn her enemies among the townspeople who have strict ideas about the role of women. VERDICT Based on the true story of horticulturist Hulda Klager (1863-1960), this is a tale about women and the way they try to find meaning and purpose in their lives. It could have been dry and boring, but Kirkpatrick's lyrical prose and attention to historical detail result in a truly great read. Recommended for readers of Suzanne Fisher Woods.

Copyright 2012 Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.